Heenwedstrijd

Toeschouwers: 17.622.

Scheidsrechter: Oliver Langford.

Scoreverloop:
1-0 Mark McNulty 3. (assist Michael Doyle)
1-1 Jamille Matt 9. (assist Greg Wylde)
1-2 Jamille Matt 19. (assist Kelvin Mellor)
2-2 Gary Roberts 51. (strafschop)

 Portsmouth F.C.: Danny Hollands (40), Adam Barton (45), Plymouth Argyle F.C.: Graham Carey (14), Peter Hartley (50), Gary Sawyer (60), Ben Purrington (85)